Forum Machete,Modelism,Hobby: 1/72 FoV "German SS Cavalry Division" - Forum Machete,Modelism,Hobby

Salt la continut

Pagina 1 din 1
  • Nu puteti crea un topic nou
  • Nu puteti replica pe acest topic

1/72 FoV "German SS Cavalry Division" Img&Review engleza

#1 Useril este offline   Panzer_Grenadire 

  • Membru senior
  • Grup: Members
  • Postari: 893
  • Inregistrat: 11-October 05

Postat 13 October 2007 - 01:03 AM

Iata si noul set de la Forces of Valor. Datorita faptului ca acest set vine pre-pictat din fabrica, am atasat si imagini cu vopsirea din fabrica. Ptr. ca eram nerabdator sa postez figurinele cat mai repede, am lasat accesoriile neatinse, desi imi plac destul de mult.
Am postat si recenzia in engleza, conform obiceiului ... :-)
Oricum, este prima recenzie a setului, eu nu am mai gasit alta pe net si sper sa va placa atat ea cat si imaginile.
Comentariile si observatiile sunt bine venite.
(Sunt foarte multumit de cum mi-a iesit camuflajul de Wehrmacht de la casti, cred ca am gasit in sfarsit culoarea de fond cea mai potrivita si care da bine si in poze)... :-(

Cristian Florescu


FORCES OF VALOR 1/72

"German SS Cavalry Division"

"Eastern Front 1942"

Manufacturer: Forces of Valor

Scale: 1/72

Set Code: 7239

Year: 2007

No. of Figures/Horses: 4/1

No. of Poses/Horses: 4/1

Aspect: Tall

Material: Soft Plastic/Hard Plastic

Optimal Period: 1944 -1945


Review

After a long period when the only set that could be used for 1/72 German Cavalry in WWII was the great Revell's "German Artillery", realized in collaboration with Preiser, in the last two years several offers on the matter appeared, trying to fill the gap in the scale. Good examples on the topic are Hat's "German Mounted Infantry", CMK's "Wehrmacht Mounted Infantry" and FOV's "German SS Cavalry Division", but still there is plenty of room, none of them succeeding to satisfy the customers from different points of view.

The last mentioned set is aimed to be analyzed here, but in spite an impressive name, it includes only one horse, being a disappointment in this regard. Indeed, with few exceptions like the brave Polish, the cavalry in WWII stopped charging the enemy and in battles such units were fighting dismounted. Nevertheless, inside a set on such theme we would rather prefer to see more mounted soldiers than on foot. In this case, almost all the figures from WWII German sets may be employed as cavalry units, but completely missing the distinctive element, the horse.

Moreover, a better name for this set should have been chosen, the one and only mounted figure having no relevance for such a title. A better one could be "MG34 Team and rider", revealing more correctly what the set incorporates. Actually, this is not the only mistake of the title, the manufacturer selecting a totally inappropriate year (1942) for some weapons and other items found on these soldiers. For instance, the first delivery to troops of the initial model of Panzerfaust (30) started in August 1943 while the model presented here (Panzerfaust 100) reached the army just in November 1944. In addition, the gaiters worn by a trooper situates the set in the Late War period, even if all are dressed in M34 tunic.

The set comes pre-painted, but distinctively from the previous FoV WWII Germans, this time the colors are better selected, at least with no bizarre additions. On the other hand, painting is quite poor, small details are not realized and everyone, with little effort, succeeds improved results. In my view, the best painted item by the factory is the horse whose basic color may be used although the owner takes the decision to upgrade the set through his hand painting.

Beside the figures and continuing its tradition in the scale, FoV has also included some diorama accessories such as a cart, a street lamp and a barrel, more or less useful on the topic. I suppose as not being the only one that would happily miss these accessories in the favor of a larger number of mounted soldiers. While the street lamp and barrel could be found some other else, the two wheels cart is quite an interesting model and has some connections with the cavalry subject, finding its place in a diorama featuring such units.

The soldiers are made of soft plastic, close to rubber and to the material used by Pegasus Hobbies and HaT in some of their multi-part sets while the accessories are done in hard plastic. Mixing different kinds of plastic inside the same set represents an unordinary advance in the scale, although the final result is pleasing.

The box allows the customer to see the content and behind the items there is an art work representing the ruins of a city.

Regarding the figures, all wear the M34 tunic and regular trousers, at two covering the boots, one has marching boots and one ankle boots with gaiters and on all the heads there are steel helmets possibly covered with camouflage cloths. Two soldiers may be used all over the WWII, the soldier with gaiters and the one with Panzerfaust are suitable only for the late part, even if they wear the early war tunics. Despite the title which makes reference to Waffen SS, taking into consideration the fact that most of the images taken in the late war period shows such troopers wearing during combat camouflage smocks, these figures are dealing better with Wehrmacht.

The uniforms mainly address the figures for warm periods, idea enhanced by the figure with rolled sleeves. Nevertheless, taking into account their thickness, it facilitates posting of these soldiers and in colder environments, except the one with rolled sleeves whose appearance in a cold place would look strange.

With reference to the gear, all possess the "Y" straps, while the presence of bread bags, canteens, gas mask containers, mess tins and Zeltbahns varies from figure to figure. Weapons and gas mask container straps are also visible, as well something indefinite, looking like the cloth case for reading map kit (Kartenwinkelmesser 27) or medical kit (Verbandpäckchen) at one figure.

In spite of being just several soldiers, the firing endowment of the set is increased from the standard MG team firepower by two Panzerfaust 100 and together with the rider, includes three Kar 98K, one MP40, one MG34, as well a pistol inside its holster.

The figures have the appropriate ammo pouches and both the MG gunner and the servant have around their necks MG cartridge belts. In fact, along the cartridge belts, the set features all the common cases for MG 34 ammo, namely the 50 rounds charger as well the MG cartridge belts metal box.

Related to the poses, these depict a MG team formed by three members walking and a nice mounted soldier. The walking figures are quite common, still good and useful, the MG gunner pose being quite rare encountered in soft plastic sets. He carries his MG34 in one of the most featured ways in reference pictures, namely on his shoulder holding it by the bipod. Moreover, he has the specific items of a MG gunner such as pistol holster, MG kit case as well a cartridge belt around the neck. The servant has elements emphasizing his role like MG metal box for cartridge belts as well another spare belt around his neck. In concordance with KStN, he has a Kar98K, but the most interesting thing at this figure, unique in 1/72 soft plastic sets, are the two Panzerfausts held in one hand. The MG ensemble is completed by another trooper, probably the commander of the squad taking into account his pose and personal weapon. Pointing to a future position where to be installed the MG, he holds his MP40 in a relaxed attitude, underlined and by the fact that his weapon misses the charger, another not so often seen issue in scale.

Nevertheless, the stunning success of this small set is represented by the mounted soldier, not because of the rider, but the horse is really amazing, perhaps the best encountered in Braille. An astonishing thoroughbred high horse, a really jumping sport one, and even if it is just walking still electrifies the viewers. Its facial expression as well proportions and muscles are extremely well detailed, making a strong impression. Even the saddle, the blanket beneath the saddle and the rolled one are properly done as well the harness. The reins and mess tin attached to the right holster are a little over-scaled, but the reins may effortlessly be made to look thinner. It should me mentioned the fact that the rider holds the reins in his hands, a realistic and rarely approach for 1/72 mounted figures.

In general, the German Army used horses for recon missions and the present rider also confirms this, looking like a genuine scout, due to his binoculars on the chest and the Kartenwinkelmesser 27 attached to the gas mask container. He has not the standard map case, but such an item could be inside the left holster of the saddle. With the Kar98K on his back, he also adopts a tranquil stance, watching the comrades while passing them by.

The uniforms of the figures are fair and small details such as buttons and creases are relatively clear. Anatomy is reasonable with palms of the MG servant a little too big, but the rest of the bodies and the facial expressions are satisfactory. Furthermore, there are no differences in gear, weapons body parts size at these soldiers which may be enclosed in the tall range of the scale.

Flash comes in small amounts but may be removed without trouble and excess of plastic appears just at the end of the rider's weapon, fact that can be ignored. As it was previously stressed, the manufacturer used two kinds of plastic for producing the set and for the figures was chosen the soft one. A small space between the shoulders and the arms clearly proves that the soldiers had at the beginning separate arms and were subsequently glued by the factory. Nevertheless, the small gap is not tainting the final product and can be filled very easy, the same opereation being necessary for covering an undesired result from the mould materialized in two tinny gaps in the arms of some figures.

Even if the figures comes prepainted, there is not necessary to remove the preceding paint if it is taken the decision to repaint them. The plastic well accepts the paint, but it has a little tendency to give a gloss aspect to it.

All the soldiers have bases and also has the street lamp. For those wanting to remove them, it is good to know that it can be done extremely fast and with the exception of the horse, all the rest stand without bases if they are appropiately cut.

From the point of view of uniforms and hight, the present set match best through others with Imex "German Troops", Pegasus Hobbies "German Mortar Teams", Hasegawa "German Infantry Attack Group", Atlantic "German Infantry", but also with Esci "German Soldiers", Revell "German Armoured Infantry", as well most of Preiser sets with reference to the German army in WWII, sets that include a little shorter figures.

Definetely, to them may join on the same diorama soldiers dressed incamouflage garement and late war tunics such as Pegasus Hobbies "Waffen SS - Set 1", Caesar "German Infantry Late War"&"German Infantry with Winter Gear" and Italeri "German Elite Troops".

Designed in principal for wargamers, FoV's "German SS Cavalry Division (Eastern Front 1942)" proves as a real asset and for diorama builders, meeting their standards of quality. Except the title which does not affect at all the value, another draw-back of the set is its high price, particulary increased by a not notable painting.

On the other hand, the main attraction is embodied by the horse, in my opinion leader in the scale, an eye-catching item which will determine many collectors, diorama and wargaming fans to take off the wallet and pay the price.

Historical Accuracy: 9

Anatomy: 9

Poses Quality: 9

Details Quality: 8

Mould Quality: 8

Sculpture: 9

Recommendation/Utility: 10

TOTAL: 9

Imagine postata

Imagine postata

Imagine postata

Imagine postata

Imagine postata

Imagine postata

Imagine postata

#2 Useril este offline   Panzer_Grenadire 

  • Membru senior
  • Grup: Members
  • Postari: 893
  • Inregistrat: 11-October 05

Postat 13 October 2007 - 01:05 AM

PICTURA FABRICII

Imagine postata

Imagine postata

Imagine postata

Imagine postata

Imagine postata

#3 Useril este offline   wurger 

  • Membru senior
  • Grup: Members
  • Postari: 4049
  • Inregistrat: 21-February 05
  • Location:Bucuresti

Postat 13 October 2007 - 01:48 AM

Mdeah !
Nu sunt foarte impresionat. Pentru cati bani ai dat pe ei ( :-) ) ar fi trebuit sa prezinte degete. In schimb unii dintre ei au mainile cat niste grapefruit-uri. Armele sunt destul de groase si ele ...si castile...Cand mai mici cand mai mari......
Calul e misto dar are copitele cam mici. Avand in vedere insa ca asta va fi partea cea mai putin vizibila intr-o diorama....Merge.
Facial expresion - my foot ! Iarta-ma dar daca ii pun langa niste Preiseri, sau chiar Airfix, o rup aia la fuga de frica mutantilor.
De laudat daruirea ta si chinezaraia vopsirii dar ca produs (mai ales cu vopsirea aia "din fabrica" - daca erau grena as fi zis ca-s aia din Startrek.
Si e cam mult spus setul de cavalerie din cauza ca-contine una bucata cal.
Nice addition - butoiu', carutul cu care se transportau corpses in lagar si felinarul. Astea suna ca o scuza: "ne pare rau ca nu-s mai multi cai da na-va un felinar."

#4 Useril este offline   Panzer_Grenadire 

  • Membru senior
  • Grup: Members
  • Postari: 893
  • Inregistrat: 11-October 05

Postat 13 October 2007 - 11:20 AM

Ai dreptate Calin, in special servantul MG-lui are ditamai palmoaiele. Probabil l-au facut asa ca sa ii incapa cele 2 Panzerfaust-uri. Castile sunt cam cat cele de la Airfix din setul Africa Korps, dar au bordura un pic cam mare si datorita acestui fapt ochii nu au mai putut iesi in poze.... :bang: Oricat m-am chinuit sa pun lumina (lampa aia smechera :angry: ) tot au reusit sa ii umbreasca.

"mai ales cu vopsirea aia "din fabrica" - daca erau grena as fi zis ca-s aia din Startrek." :-D ;-) - intr-adevar este cam ciudata rau, dar macar nu au mai pus verde fosforescent ca in setul trecut, au facut ceva progrese cei de la FOV :angry: :-)
Oricum, tot fraieri raman, cum poti sa ii pui unui set in care ai Panzerfaus-uri si gaieti titlul 1942? :-( :hammer: :-(
Noroc cu gloaba si carut ca altfel era slab rau setul...cica cavalerie, astia vor cu o floare sa faca primavara... :bang:

#5 Userul este online   Z-mare 

  • Membru senior
  • Grup: Moderator
  • Postari: 12687
  • Inregistrat: 07-December 04
  • Location:Sebes -Alba

Postat 13 October 2007 - 05:50 PM

Pacat ca stradania de ai vopsi este umbrita de nestradania de ai debavura!

#6 Useril este offline   Panzer_Grenadire 

  • Membru senior
  • Grup: Members
  • Postari: 893
  • Inregistrat: 11-October 05

Postat 13 October 2007 - 11:05 PM

Te cam inseli Z-mare, si de aceasta data chiar poti sa faci o comparatie. Uita-te de exemplu la calaret din poza 4 (debavuat) si cel din poza 9, prima de dupa cea care prezinta cutia (nedebavuat). Ambele poze sunt din acelasi unghi si poti vedea diferentele, uita-te la bavurile care erau pe casca, ca sa nu mai vorbesc de cele de pe haine.... :angry:
Se poate sa mai fi ratat in unele locuri, unele bavuri sunt imposibil de detectat cu ochiul liber datorita dimensiunilor, de asemenea unele cute sau cusaturi ale hainelor pot fi interpretate ca bavuri, dar asta este, soldatii sunt chiar debavuati, atat cat am reusit dupa ce am repetat operatiunea de vreo 3 ori.... :-)
Si uite si cateva exemple dintre alte zeci de astfel de operatiuni pe care le-au avut de suferit acesti soldati, ca toti ai mei de altfel... :-( :-( De asemenea, acestea sunt doar pe o parte a unui singur soldat, iar in zona gatului si a fetei este o adevarata placere debavuarea....-) :angry: :-D
Niste mici stradanii.... ;-) ;

Thumbnail atasat

  • Imagine atasata: x.JPG

Aceasta postare a fost editata de Panzer_Grenadire: 13 October 2007 - 11:42 PM


#7 Userul este online   Z-mare 

  • Membru senior
  • Grup: Moderator
  • Postari: 12687
  • Inregistrat: 07-December 04
  • Location:Sebes -Alba

Postat 14 October 2007 - 11:51 AM

Bun, ai dreptate. Eu voiam doar sa te ajut sa faci un lucru ca lumea. Daca nu vrei eu nu te pot ajuta nicicum.

#8 Useril este offline   Panzer_Grenadire 

  • Membru senior
  • Grup: Members
  • Postari: 893
  • Inregistrat: 11-October 05

Postat 14 October 2007 - 12:23 PM

Chiar am nevoie de orice sfat bun si sunt recunoscator ptr. acestea. Chiar imi doresc sa ii fac cat mai bine posibil.... :-D
de altfel, de-a lungul timpului mi-ai dat sfaturi foarte bune, cum ar fi gaurirea tevilor de mortiere la seturile care includ astfel de piese...

Insa remarcele legate de nestradania de a nu ii debavua, erau un pic cam exagerate si nefondate.... :-(
Un singur soldat de acest fel imi ia cam 8 ore ptr. a il picta, si crede-ma ca nu as lasa bavurile sa strice aceasta munca.... ;-)
Astfel ca incerc sa inlatur cat mai multe dintre ele....Este posibil sa mai ratez unele dintre ele, la altele sa nu pot ajunge sub nici o forma, dar ma straduiesc destul de mult, dupa cum s-a vazut si in exemplul pe care l-am atasat un pic mai sus.
De altel, soldatii mei, nu ca ar fi ai mei :angry: :-) sunt destul de bine debavuati avand in vedere scara. Daca nu ma crezi, uita-te pe cutiile Preiser in care sunt prezentati in diorame soldatii acestei companii (care cred ca este cea mai tare in materie de figurine). Vei putea sa observi acolo bavuri impresionante care au fost ratate de super-profesionistii acestei companii, precum si ochi la figurinele lor... :-(

#9 Userul este online   Z-mare 

  • Membru senior
  • Grup: Moderator
  • Postari: 12687
  • Inregistrat: 07-December 04
  • Location:Sebes -Alba

Postat 14 October 2007 - 06:55 PM

Citeaza

Vei putea sa observi acolo bavuri impresionante care au fost ratate de super-profesionistii acestei companii, precum si ochi la figurinele lor...
Tovarasa, si Gigel a varsat calimara, nu numai eu! :-P :-P

#10 Useril este offline   curec_christian 

  • Membru senior
  • Grup: Members
  • Postari: 606
  • Inregistrat: 13-December 04

Postat 14 October 2007 - 11:15 PM

Salut,

Aspru Z-Mare (he, he, he... :-P ).

Oricum - parerea mea este ca figurinele sunt foarte prost executate.
- chipuri de mutant...
- arme strimbe si deformate...
- maini supradimensionate...
- echipament deformat...
- calul un pic cam deformat...

In totalitate as putea zice ca sunt o gramada de defecte. Cel putin comparind cu figurinele pe care le fac eu acum.

Scuze - dar oricit te-ai chinui sa faci din ca... bici, oricum nu o sa pocneasca. Si nu poti sa elimini cu totul bavurile si deformarile rezultate din procesul de injectie. :-P


Christian

PS - dupa mine, la scara asta sau esti profesor in injectie sau treci pe figurine de metal...

Aceasta postare a fost editata de curec_christian: 14 October 2007 - 11:18 PM


Arata acest topic


Pagina 1 din 1
  • Nu puteti crea un topic nou
  • Nu puteti replica pe acest topic

1 useri citesc topicul
0 membri, 1 vizitatori, 0 utilizatori anonimi